Okay. I'm surprised this hasn't been asked yet.
Whenever a new album is released, it is usually compared to the previous one.
So just wondering: Which one, do you think is better, and why?

__________________
give me a hand, it's time to show the new eyes their home.

For me its sometimes. The production on BMYL makes it seem a little less soulful along with the extra instruments, and the power of the vocals on Sometimes just make it the best album ever. Also, while BMYL has a combination of absolute standouts and some not so standout but still amazing ones, whereas Sometimes is consistantly brilliant.
Also, sometimes was the first, and nothing beats that.

__________________
"I feel like a pile of 100 dollar bills sitting on top of a cherry cheesecake" George
<A HREF="www.cityandcolourforum.com/sincerityoversimplechords">Check Out My BLOG!</A>

I have to agree with most of that. But I find it really hard to choose between them anyway. I still think that some of the lyrics are better on Bring Me Your Love.

It's hard to choose for me.
There are songs that I absolutely LOVE on both albums: Like Knives, Delaware, Day Old Hate, Constant Knot and Body in a Box.

But in terms of OVERALL. Sometimes is better, always.

__________________
give me a hand, it's time to show the new eyes their home.

i cant choose - i uess sometimes but i accidently voted BMYL.

and listening to thrones - would this not be amazing for him to play live? and 2ndly it reall piseses me off that AOF wouldnt play this live

__________________

I LOVE em both but sometimes has more soul, more emotion. Ya know? Its less production, more dallas.

__________________
Ten thousand times I will scream
Over and over until you notice me
Until my voice breaks
And all this heartache
Gently fades away..

You almost can't really choose between the two because they are so different, even if they are made by the same guy. Sometimes to me seems more raw and the songs seem heavier, not as upbeat as some of the songs on BMYL. BMYL is for sure more folky, which at first I was a little unsure about, I was so used of the acoustic guitar sound and then all of a sudden there were other instruments involved, but I have to say, it's grown on me and of course, I have come to love it. I just can't choose between the two! Sometimes has Live Knives and Hello, I'm In Delaware.. yet BMYL has Constant Knot and As Much As I Ever Could.. and of course Sleeping Sickness (looove) Even the Live cd is so different.

God that man is amazing.

__________________

i now officially love you for saying that
they're my ultimate favourites.

__________________
give me a hand, it's time to show the new eyes their home.

Hehe, Mine too.. they are my favourites of the favourites. haha.

__________________

Constant Knot, Casey's Song, and Delaware are my 'ultimate favs' :P

__________________
Ten thousand times I will scream
Over and over until you notice me
Until my voice breaks
And all this heartache
Gently fades away..