This review comes as a guest post from Wicky. I’ll take this oppertunity to to thank him deeply for his contribution, and anyone else who wants to do a review - please say so. Great job Wicky.

Release Date: November 1, 2005
Track listing:
- …Off by Heart
- Like Knives
- Hello, I’m in Delaware
- Save Your Scissors
- In the Water, I am Beautiful
- Day Old Hate
- Sam Malone
- Comin’ Home
- Casey’s Song
- Sometimes (I Wish)
Like white on black, Dallas Green’s debut solo album is quite a contrast to that of his regular band Alexisonfire. Originally only available at live shows or off the internet, City and Colour - as Dallas named his project - soon garnered the attention of the Alexisonfire faithful, and a studio album was assembled. The album, featuring a total of 10 songs, was well received by both Alexisonfire fans, and listeners who had no such appreciation for the screaming tunes of Alexis. The heavier listeners were won over from the sincere music and lyrics as well as the fact that city and colour was still considered indie and associated with Alexis, where as the traditional listeners enjoyed the alternative to the over produced pop-music of today. Whichever you were, the album was well received.
First impressions are supposed to tell a lot about someone, however this is not the case with this album as the opening track, …Off By Heart, is the most bland of the album. However with the next track a shimmer of hope is starting to appear from the album. A track which sounds better after a few listens; Like Knives displays a glimpse of the vulnerable work Dallas Green creates with regularity. Hello, I’m In Delaware appears to be the first of two tracks on the record dealing with time away from home. Although audibly calm, the track shows the evident hardships touring places on Dallas, who tends to tour extensively with Alexis.
Produced as a single, Save Your Scissors appears to be. With the sincere lyrics, hidden with a happy-go-lucky tune, the song seems as if it was produced as a hit, and boy did that hit the mark. Although not the highlight of this album, Save Your Scissors is a solid song which should not go over looked, but grows tiresome after repeated listening.
From track 6 on, Sometimes is solid, if not classic. Day Old Hate shows the most sincere thing to come out of Canada since Sarah McLachlan hit the scene, with beautiful vocals, an accompanying piano tune, and a very warm, but chilling melody. Continuing on with Sam Malone - one of the first songs Dallas wrote as a teenager - a good rhythm appears, later more prominent on Bring Me Your Love. The rhythm is ridden throughout the song with an accompanying lead guitar track until the riff of the album is reached, sung to; “And I know, there is - some place I can go, where no one knows my name”, borrowed from a similar tune by Alexisonfire.
The Highlight of the album comes with the second single; Comin’ Home. From the opening lick, to the solemn lyrics, this song is the cream of the crop. The song tells of travels across Canada, and of a relationship, possible on the rocks because of it. A chilling lead guitar track, plays throughout the song encouraging thoughts of what else Dallas has up his sleeve. But the real treat comes with the bridge. “You told me life was a risk”, he sings. Emotion pouring out into the lyrics, the song breaks in the chorus until the end of the song, and so ends a song that won’t soon be forgotten.
Sometimes (I wish) is the end to the album, and is a huge contrast to the opener. Returning again to some sort of rhythm, last seen on Sam Malone, the tambourine featured on this track is the only form of percussion featured on the album. The song, features Dallas asking his love, if life would be different if he was just a “simple man”. The song, after a good five minutes, ends with the sung word; “Sometimes”, rightfully naming the album with just the single word.
In the end, the album seems stark in comparison to Alexisonfire here, yet there is more than enough emotion to make up for it. The stripped down style may not be for everyone - but the lyrics and music is sincere if you are tired of what else is playing on the radio. And if you are this is a great place to start, as this album is absolutely solid. However, don’t expect much more than what it really is, as it’s with the follow up, Bring Me Your Love, that Dallas Green begins to find himself, and take a fuller direction with City and Colour. Dallas’ calm tunes and raw emotion are front and centre here, and his voice is one in a million, if you’re looking for some raw - yet real, this is for you.
Overall - 7.5/10






